The draw is the ice cream itself: more than 75 flavors of Hershey's, scooped to order in generous portions. It is a brand a lot of people around here say is hard to find elsewhere, and with that many options on the board, half the fun is standing at the case trying to narrow it down.
What sets the stop apart is where it lives. The ice cream counter is tucked inside That's Karma, a roomy consignment and gift boutique of some 4,000 square feet, stocked with local artisan goods, toys, and imported finds, so a cone comes with a browse through the shelves. Reviewers tend to describe the shop as friendly and a little nostalgic, and the owner has been known to step out and chat with visitors.
Past the scoops, the menu stretches to sundaes, milkshakes, ice cream flights, and made-to-order creations, along with fresh-squeezed lemonade and a candy counter, with dairy-free and gluten-free options that customers with sensitivities are quick to point out. It sits right on West Main Street in the middle of downtown Easley's shops and restaurants, an easy stop while you work your way down the block.